I might be a little behind on this... but didn't New York just pass gay marriage?! Woah. I almost missed it considering the cover of the New York Post:
Anyway....
I was perusing the Huffington Post and I found
THIS article. Rabbi Shmuley thinks its funny that while gays are pushing the traditional institution of marriage, heteros are afraid of hardcore commitment. Just today one of my buddies said, "Why would I get married? I'm having sex." Obviously, there is more to marriage than sex. More to relationships than sex. More to commitment than sex. And more to love than sex. I found the article pretty compelling and kind of challenging as a straight person. We sure do take our straight relationships for granted.
Sort of on the other side I came across
THIS blog entitled "Sex is good, Sex is Great" (pt. 1, 2, 3) (also where I got the photo from). And this guy is advocating for pre-marital sex, bashing some crazy Christians, and is not so interested in marriage. I found the comments very enlightening as well. I think my main concerns/questions for him would be
1. What is marriage? (What's it for? Is it necessary? etc?) Because he seems to be advocating for premarital sex, and not advocating for marriage really at all. And I guess I agree with him, atheists shouldn't feel any pressure to get married or not have sex before they are married. So what's the point of marriage? Should we keep it around?
(Sure, I have my Christiany answer in my head, but I'll spare you)
As far as I can tell it's a public commitment usually under some governing body (government, religion, culture, you name it). Without the governing body defining it somehow, then I guess it's a lifetime partner that you communicate with and figure out whatever marriage is for the two of you (monogamy or not, kids or not, finances, extended family, the list is endless). Then there's the whole kid issue... Cause once you have one of those, life/marriage/relationships/family/sex/commitment gets multiplied in complication (c.f.
Babies are not a myth). And chances are you're just going to pass down the poopstorm to your babies.
2. What is sex? This is more a question I have for the Christians he is tirading against. Dude, get some definitions. Because you will come to find Christians with a "no touching policy" all the way to "duh, I have sex" and everything in between in all traditions, full of guilt or guiltless, and all with a rational to irrational argument all using the same sources. Isn't it wonderful? I love living in paradox. (I also found
Scarleteen an interesting sex ed reference.)
Any ideas here? Should we all be pulling for institutionalized marriage or de-institutionalized marriage? What does it mean? As far as human history goes, it's pretty recent that we've gained the ability to choose are partners, and in many parts of the world the privilege still doesn't exist. Maybe we need to go back to bartering our sexuality for land and animals, or arranged marriages to keep peace between tribes. Maybe we'll never figure it out. Maybe committed monogomous loving post marital sexual relationships with lots of babies is the best way to go. Or maybe not?
Bleh.